A man is sent to a non-stop rumination loophole by his best friend for not telling him what he did to upset her: 'She refused to name anything specific I had said or done, and kept saying "It would be an argument"'

Advertisement
  • man putting his finger on his forehead
  • How to stop ruminating?

    About a year ago, my best friend sent me a manifesto out of the blue telling me what a terrible friend I was and left a long, rambling, accusatory voice message (we communicated primarily through voice notes) calling me passive
  • aggressive, saying I played. games, that I was for tat, didn't want to have a conversation with her, and treated her poorly.
  • I was shocked, because the last few messages we'd exchanged were completely normal, or so I thought. We hadn't been. fighting, but she clearly had a one sided resentment she had not shared with me. I asked
  • her to clarify what she meant, because I was completely lost and didn't know what she was talking about. I asked what I had done or what I could do differently, because she'd not outlined anything specific, just a lot of vague
  • accusations and character judgments. She refused to name anything specific I had said or done, and kept saying "It would be an argument" if she told me what I'd done. This went in
  • young woman looking at smartphone screen
  • circles for weeks and I exhausted myself begging for context. At some point, she said she 'needed some time' to figure out how to articulate what she wanted. I said okay and waited for her to respond. 10 days later, she still had
  • not spoken to me. I had a feeling I should just block her and move on, but against my better judgment, (and even a coin. flip) I reached out to her to ask how much more time she thought she might need.
  • She responded that evening and instead of clarifying anything, she put more on the pile and said "we're having two separate conversations and the theme of both is l feel like I'm going to be told what to think and how
  • to feel" Meanwhile, she'd been telling me what I thought and what I felt for weeks. I told her I had no intention of doing so, I was just seeking clarification for what she meant so I could change how I interacted with her. But
  • any difference of perspective or request for clarification was ruled as me "arguing" with her. This went back and forth and she would heavily sigh and say "I don't know what else I can say" in a tone of
  • irritated resignation. I then told her that I couldn't change my behavior when I didn't know what bothered her and that all I could say was I acknowledge how she felt, but there's nothing I could really do with the
  • information. She then told me it helped to hear me acknowledge her feelings, and she asked to move forward "with a clean. slate" and asked how she could help with repair. I said I needed resolution first and to know what she
  • meant by all the things she said, otherwise it was bound to happen again and I would feel like I was walking on eggshells waiting to get ambushed. I said after I had an understanding, I would be happy to move forward
  • with a clean slate. It just kept going in circles so I said I didn't see the point of engaging in the conversation anymore if she refused to tell me what I'd done to upset her and if she didn't trust me enough
  • to let me know. I was sick of engaging in conflict dragged on and on for weeks. I like to hash things out and put them to bed. She said the point was to express her feelings. She then said "I feel like this has to do more with being
  • right than being kind or being a friend" and then. refused to play my last voice message in response. We have never spoken since. I could have sent a text or email, but instead, I let her have the last word and figured it
  • really didn't matter what I said, that she'd made her mind up about me. I sometimes get angry at the mindfuck of it all. At myself especially, for entertaining a conversation where I was
  • on the backfoot to prove myself to someone who refused to engage in conflict in a fair way. For not noticing sooner that she was not seeking any resolution, but only wanted to punish me. For all of the time and energy I wasted. I
  • generally don't think about it anymore, but once in a while, it still bothers me. Have you ever had a bad falling out with a friend that plays over and over in your mind? What helped you to ease the memory?
  • I've written letters I'll never send, talked to people about it, etc. But none of the normal things seem to help.
  • pen and paper

Tags

Scroll Down For The Next Article